The Nebraska Supreme Court on Friday upheld a 39-year-old Scottsbluff man’s conviction on a “revenge porn” charge, rejecting his attorney’s argument that the law violated his right to free speech.
It is believed to have been the first time the state’s high court addressed the constitutionality of the state law passed in 2019.
According to court records, in 2022, in the midst of divorce proceedings, William Zitterkopf sent his ex-wife a screenshot of another woman taken from a sexually explicit video.
Prosecutors said that in doing so, Zitterkopf had violated a Nebraska law that makes it illegal to share or threaten to share sexual images of another person without their expressed consent.
A jury ultimately agreed, finding him guilty of the unlawful distribution of an intimate image.
People are also reading…
Last year, after Scotts Bluff District Judge Leo Dobrovolny sentenced Zitterkopf to three years of probation and 45 days in jail, Zitterkopf appealed.
His attorney, Michael Wilson, argued that the district court had erred by rejecting Zitterkopf’s constitutional challenge of the law on the grounds that it was overbroad on its face and violated constitutional guarantees of free speech.
The Nebraska Attorney General’s Office, on the other side, argued defendants couldn’t even challenge a statute for being overbroad, despite precedent where the court said otherwise.
In Friday’s decision, the Supreme Court said they found no reason to overrule their prior case law.
Justice Lindsey Miller-Lerman said the court, like some other state courts, recognizes that there may be reasonable arguments that the speech prohibited by Nebraska’s law and similar laws in other states should be unprotected.
“However, we do not find it to be within an established category, and we decline to recognize a new category of unprotected speech when the U.S. Supreme Court has not done so,” she wrote.
The court went on to analyze whether the restriction furthered a compelling interest and was narrowly tailored to achieve it, finding that it did.
Miller-Lerman said the state has a compelling interest in protecting the personal privacy of its residents, and the conduct criminalized under the state law constitutes a “significant invasion of privacy and presents the potential of significant harm to the victims of such conduct.”
While Wilson had argued the statute should have required an intent to intimidate, threaten or harass the victim, the court said the harm was the same regardless.
Wilson also argued that the “revenge porn” law sweeps in several legitimate communications, from images and video taken or discovered by journalists to innocent photos and videos of nude or underwear-clad babies and toddlers, shared with family members.
Miller-Lerman said the court rejected that argument, too. First Amendment concerns in those cases could be addressed through later challenges if the state prosecutes such a case, she said.
Download the new Journal Star News Mobile App
Top Journal Star photos for August 2024
Tae’veon Coleman, 7, (left) waits to cast his line as the sun sets during a Community Lake day hosted by Big Gumdrop Outdoors at Oak Lake Park on Friday, Aug. 9, 2024, in Lincoln. Big Gumdrop Outdoors, is ,a nonprofit created by Elijah Riley, a Lincoln native and UNL student, to help kids connect with nature and play outside.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
Travis Ruel and Alanna White, 9, of Lincoln, interact with Patches, a 1-year-old Catahoula dog, through the glass of her kennel at the Pieloch Pet Adoption Center on Friday. Patches has been at the shelter since June 19. The Capital Humane Society is offering a “Full House” promotion where adoption fees for all dogs are reduced to $100 until Sunday because the shelter is nearly full.
KATY COWELL, Journal Star
Framed through the grate of a fire pit, Olivia Dagget-Keagle, 9, blows out the fire on her blackened marshmallow during a Community Lake day hosted by Big Gumdrop Outdoors at Oak Lake Park on Friday, Aug. 9, 2024, in Lincoln. Big Gumdrop Outdoors, is ,a nonprofit created by Elijah Riley, a Lincoln native and UNL student, to help kids connect with nature and play outside.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
A bicyclist rides along the Billy Wolff Trail near the Union Plaza Amphitheater on Wednesday. After 13 straight days of highs of 90 degrees or above, including 100 on Monday, a cool front brought relief to Lincoln, with a high of only 75 on Tuesday. Wednesday’s high, which reached into the upper 80s, will likely be the warmest for several days. The National Weather Service forecasts highs in the 70s to around 80 through the weekend, about 10 degrees below normal for this time of year.
KENNETH FERRIERA, Journal Star
Jordan Jones, 6, and her brother Sincere, 7, (from left) react while riding the Super Drop ride at the Heart of America Carnival during the Lancaster County Super Fair at the Sandhills Global Event Center on Saturday, Aug. 3, 2024, in Lincoln.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
Todd Heiser of Lincoln makes one of five trips of the day to drop off tree debris at a collection site at Holmes Lake Park on Monday. J.J. Yost, assistant director of Parks and Recreation, said the debris drop-off site at Holmes Lake has been one of the busiest — and it’s also one of the smallest. The city has brought equipment to all the drop-off sites to consolidate tree debris. At Holmes Lake, workers also used a grinder to further process debris. Yost said the city is encouraging residents to use other sites, which include Seng Park (south of the ballfields); Woods Park (south lot off of J Street); Oak Lake Park (main lot off of Charleston Street); and Hofeling Enterprises, 2200 South Folsom Court. City parks sites will accept debris until Aug. 19.
JUSTIN WAN, Journal Star
Nowear BMX’s Sam Bussell (top right) performs a trick on his bike during a performance at the Sandhills Global Event Center on Saturday.
KENNETH FERRIERA, Journal Star
Wilber native David Rogers, 10 (first right) holds his cousin William Mays, 3, as they dance during the 63rd annual Wilber Czech Festival held in Downtown Wilber on Saturday, Aug. 3, 2024.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
A wild horse jumps onto its back as it tries to throw off a rope held by Troy Graybill (from front) Chris Hajek, and Scott Graves as they try to saddle it during the wild horse race a during the final day of Nebraska’s Big Rodeo at the Garfield County Fairgrounds on Saturday, July 27, 2024, in Burwell.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
Nebraska Capitol groundskeepers Lexis Funk (left) and Heather Dinslage collect fallen tree branches Thursday in Lincoln.
JUSTIN WAN, Journal Star
JC Brager’s Sawyer Bokowski (left) fields a ball as Papillion-La Vista South’s Derek Geist runs to third base during the second inning of a National division Class A Legion baseball tournament game against on Saturday, July 27, 2024, at Den Hartog Field.
KATY COWELL Journal Star
Harry Tompkin, owner of Palace Glass Co., hands off a piece of stained glass to Kelly Mathes (from left) as they sort through inventory on Wednesday, July 31, 2024, in Lincoln. After 43 years of creating stained glass, Harry Tompkin plans to close his shop by September. Most of the remaining pieces are rejuvenation projects or those that were planned before his decision to close.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
Burwell’s Keelin Swett, 12, blows a bubble with her gum while waiting in the staging area behind the chutes during the final day of Nebraska’s Big Rodeo at the Garfield County Fairgrounds on Saturday, July 27, 2024, in Burwell.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
New teachers gather for the Lincoln Public Schools New Educator Kickoff on Monday at Southwest High School.
JUSTIN WAN, Journal Star
Bob Swanson uses a chainsaw to clean up large fallen branches after a storm pummeled the city Wednesday in Lincoln.
KENNETH FERRIERA, Journal Star
Quade Peterson of Litchfield is dragged underneath a wild horse while attempting to saddle it in the wild horse race competition during the final day of Nebraska’s Big Rodeo at the Garfield County Fairgrounds on Saturday, July 27, 2024, in Burwell.
KENNETH FERRIERA Journal Star
Akroyd Darkgrove, played by Shade Ingraham (left), has popcorn thrown at him by Jacob Parman, 7, of Fargo, North Dakota, during a performance of “Phantom of Darkgrove” at the Denman and Mary Mallory Kountze Memorial Theatre at Eugene T. Mahoney State Park in July. Audience interaction is a big part of what makes the melodramas at the park special, crew members said. The crowd is encouraged to respond vocally to musical cues throughout the play and throw popcorn at the villain.
KENNETH FERRIERA, Journal Star
Noah Wong, 7, unzips backpacks for the assembly line to place school supplies inside it during Spreetail’s annual Back(Pack) to School Event on Friday.
KATY COWELL, Journal Star
Nebraska Volleyball head coach John Cook poses for a photo in front of the chutes before the Grand Entry on the final day of Nebraska’s Big Rodeo at the Garfield County Fairgrounds on Saturday, July 27, 2024, in Burwell.
KENNETH FERRIERA, Journal Star
Matt Rhule (center) leads a group of participants inside to cool off during his “She’s Got Game” girls football camp on Saturday, July 27, 2024, at Memorial Stadium.
KATY COWELL Journal Star
Nazar Durzhynskyi, 9, focuses on keeping the ball off the ground using his racket while participating in a practice drill during a tennis camp held for Ukrainian children at Woods Tennis Center on Thursday.
KENNETH FERRIERA, Journal Star
Reach the writer at 402-473-7237 or lpilger@journalstar.com.
On Twitter @LJSpilger
Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter
Get the latest in local public safety news with this weekly email.
Source link : http://www.bing.com/news/apiclick.aspx?ref=FexRss&aid=&tid=66ba34e1789b44c4beff97075aafed70&url=https%3A%2F%2Fjournalstar.com%2Fnews%2Fstate-regional%2Fcrime-courts%2Fnebraska-supreme-court-rejects-challenge-to-scottsbluff-mans-revenge-porn-conviction%2Farticle_6d0404ae-568f-11ef-b466-dffef1ec40bc.html&c=8569549288845362616&mkt=en-us
Author :
Publish date : 2024-08-12 02:59:00
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source.